tv Fault Lines Al Jazeera September 29, 2013 7:00pm-7:31pm EDT
>> welcome to al jazeera, i'm david shuster in new york. the federal government government faces a shut down tuesday if the spending bill does not pass the house of congress. it pass the one house but if it delayed the affordable care act. the senate is expected to reject the bill. if the senate takes action it will be to send another version back to the house with no conditions related to obamacare. >> israel security services arrested a man who they believe is a spy for iran. he's a belgium citizen of iranian origin, recruited by the
revolutionary guard. it comes as benyamin netanyahu prepares to talk about the nuclear threat tomorrow at the u.n. general assembly. >> a week after the deadly attack in kenya, the government is facing questions over whether it ignored warnings. indications were known a year ago that al-shabab was plans attacks at the westgate mall. operatives were alerted to a plan involving an attack at the mall perhaps a year ago. they were the headlines. the latest on line on the website. fault lines is next. i'm david shuster. thank you for watching. a valley, divided by the border. on one side, el paso - on the
other, ciudad juarez. >> el paso reaps tremendous benefit from the activities going on in juarez, and vice versa. this is the largest border city in the world. >> el paso has the lowest crime rate in the united states. juarez, once known as a booming industrial city and a model of economic progress in mexico, has become infamous as the murder capital of the world. >> since i came here there was something really heavy moving in the city. it was a chaotic collapsing of forces. >> the official story is that the sinaloa and juarez cartels are battling for the city and the access it provides to the us drug market only a few hundred meters away. >> now there's an estimated 100-200 thousand addicts in the city. that means every street corner is worth killing for. cause every street corner is a point of sale now.
every little tienda is a point of sale. >> more than 8,000 people have been killed here since 2008, the year mexican president calderon sent in the army to carry out his offensive against the cartels. 3951 people were recorded murdered in 2010 alone. we traveled to juarez try to understand how human life here came to be worth so much less than the drugs being trafficked through. >> my question was, at the beginning, okay the whole country is in a fight, why has juarez been the bloodiest? this must be related to just the story of this city. >>the first game on juarez's newest football field. it's being played to mark a year since 16 people, some of them
young members of the home team, were gunned down by a juarez cartel street gang in this neighborhood of villa salvarcar. president calderon provoked the city's anger when he dismissed the massacre as a fight between rival drug gangs. luz maria davila, the mother of two of the young men killed, became the voice of that indignation in pictures that flashed around the world. today, mexico's education minister, the governor of chihuahua and the mayor of juarez are here to show they're serious about fighting crime, giving juarez's teenagers an alternative to gangs and low-level street selling. and though 5 people have been arrested and charged with the murder of her sons marcos and jose luis, she has little faith that the government will bring those guilty to justice - even though it's a high-profile case.
the salvarcar massacre undermined the mexican government's claim that over 90 percent of the almost 40,000 casualties in calderon's war on drugs are involved in the narco-trade. that those who die are dirty. >> the fact is the mexican government admits only 5% of the murders have ever been investigated so it is absolutely a lie that 90% are dirty. no one knows who they are. but if you go to the morgue - which the secretary of state hillary clinton doesn't do, and which the president of mexico filipe calderon doesn't do, which the president of the united states doesn't do-ou find on the slabs you'll find a bunch of god damned poor people. >> more than a decade ago, author charles bowden dubbed juarez the laboratory of our future. now that future has arrived, more dystopian than he could have predicted.
>> what i thought was there was going to be an explosion. but i never thought we'd go from 2 - 300 murders a year to 3000 a year. it was beyond my imagination. >> but the dimension the violence has taken is undeniably real. in juarez, there's a trail of blood that journalists can follow day by day, hour by hour. it's a saturday morning, and three men have been shot. two were in a car that is now empty and riddled with bullets. a third, a bystander, was caught in the cross fire and fell here. >> so there's a body covered by a blanket right there about 50 feet away, this shooting happened about thirty minutes ago, right in the middle of this neighborhood. the amazing thing is how little this has really changed life in this neighborhood. i mean a block down you have kids playing soccer, you have kids walking around the street here. i mean we're fifty feet from the body, and we're the only ones standing here even paying attention to what's going on.
>> later that afternoon, the death toll climbs. on this saturday, it will reach 16. three young men have been gunned down at a car dealership. later, we learn that two are us citizens and have been attending private high schools in el paso, where their families have moved to safety. so when we got here, this is a really busy road, 7-8 lanes across right through downtown, and traffic was going by. now they've blocked off all traffic completely - and the media was here, there was local media. now the media have all left. the speculation at the scene here is that this is a very unsafe place to be because it seems like this was a very powerful family that this happened to. >> let's go... >> yet another execution, here
in the middle of a major intersection. a municipal police officer who had just finished his shift, is slumped over the wheel of his truck. we watch as the evidence is carefully catalogued and collected. but according to the mexican government's own figures, 95% of murders presumed to involve organized crime are never investigated at all. only one or two percent ever result in a sentence. >> what you're seeing when you go to the crime scene is just a charade. the people picking up the bullets, the cartridges, and measuring everything are absolutely doing it, but they know absolutely that nothing will be done with it. we're not the only ones taking in this grim spectacle. some observers might be paid by drug gangs to keep watch at the scene of a crime. others are just watching life unfold, and death grip their city - avoiding clear sight of anything that might make them the next target. here selective vision is a product of a justice system that seems to operate blindly.
>> impunity is creating killers, a generation of people willing to kill. ok there's the problem we can have a solution. but without any investigation, any clarification of what is going on, how can you solve the problem? >> the lack of genuine investigation and prosecution frustrates sandra rodriguez nieto. an investigative reporter for el diario newspaper, she's writing a book about impunity. >> the violence in juarez didn't start 3 years ago, it started many years ago. there's like a culture deep in the city, a culture of violence and impunity. that was the case before the war started. everybody knew in the city that you could kill and nobody is going to punish you. >> sandra has read her share of investigation files from the state prosecutor's office -
many, she says, incomplete, lacking interviews with crime scene witnesses. she says she's been told that under previous governments, the prosecutor's office sent evidence to chihuahua for archiving - leaving investigators in juarez with nothing to work from. >> so the system was designed to not find the murderers? >> yes >> to protect the murders in a way? >> what is the other explanation if you don't ask questions? if you don't ask anybody, "did you see a car? how many people shoot?" i mean there is no questions.
at least 230,000 people have fled the juarez area since calderon launched his war on the cartels in 2006. like doctor sergio and his wife guadalupe, more than half have fled to the united states. dr. sergio had a successful medical practice - he ran a private clinic, a nursing school, and did charity work. then, in may of 2009, he was kidnapped.
he was released after his family paid a ransom. a year and a half later, extortionists sent him a message, demanding he pay what is known in juarez as "the quota" - a fee to protect his clinic. there was no one to call for help. like most people we spoke to in juarez, dr. sergio doesn't trust the federal police force that is supposed to be protecting him from organized crime.
>> but unlike dr. sergio, most people in juarez don't have the means to flee to the us. back across the border, jesus juarez and his family are packing up too, and moving - to a different part of town. rows of homes lie abandoned, stripped by looters. entire neighborhoods like this one lie empty - vacated by maquila workers like jesus, many because they had been laid off and could no longer afford to pay the government-backed mortgages on houses they'd been encouraged to buy. for more than 40 years, the city's primary legal economy had revolved around the maquilas - assembly plants which offered foreign manufacturers cheap
labor and proximity to us markets. mexicans moved to the border town lured by the promise of work. the city became the blue print for the north american free trade agreement implemented in 1994. as nafta reshaped mexico's land-ownership laws, slashed tariffs on us imports and allowed subsidized us corn to flood the country, mexico's agricultural sector was devastated. hundreds of thousands were forced to migrate to the united states in search of income - many more moved to juarez. the city grew. maria lopez is a labor organizer. for her security, we can't use her real name or show her face.
to maria, the fall out from the economic crisis have made nafta's false promises clear. in 2008, as us manufacturers faltered or failed, some 80 to 100,000 workers in juarez lost their jobs. now many scour the industrial parks for temp contracts meted out by agencies - jobs with few benefits and no security, some as short as 15 days. but back across the border, we find a more optimistic outlook. >> if you're sending something to your mexican factory, this is the address you send it to.... you don't send it to mexico. >> alan russell is the president and co-founder of tecma, an el paso-headquartered company that has provided workers and facilities in juarez to us manufacturers since 1986.
>> we were nafta before there was nafta. we were able to move products across the border and have it transformed into a finished product and bring it back again without duty on the material only paying duty on the value added. so it was exactly what nafta turned out to be. >> russell says the end of the recession in the united states is bringing business back to the maquila zones, in spite of the violence in juarez. and tecma is hiring again. >> certainly by the end of this year i think we'll be back equivalent to where we were before the recession started in mexico. with the end of this recession, we now have 8 million square feet of empty manufacturing space right here in juarez ready to go - lights are on. we have 60,000 employees that were laid off during the recession that are ready to go back to work. so if you want your product manufactured turned quickly short lead time, you're going to chose juarez now than you would
chose china. >> a recovery means more people will be working, many for minimum wage: 59 pesos or just under 5 us dollars a day. the average maquila worker takes home about 50 dollars a week. at tecma, entry level workers make slightly more than that - one young woman we spoke to said she made 54 dollars, another 58. but more jobs will not change the disparity on which the maquila industry is founded, and which has shaped the city. >> these people that came to work in the maquiladoras, they just came to work but they didn't find houses they didn't find schools. they didn't find where to take
the kids while they were in the maquiladoras so there was a heavy social problem years ago. >> and suddenly these people get into a war dynamic. and these people just recruit these kids in the streets for 200 dollars and they easily get into the fight. >> their parents have never gotten ahead, their parents are slaves. they're working 5 1/2 days a week for low wages. the kids join gangs. they join gangs because they're rational. it's better to have some money in your teens and be killed by the age of 20 than be a slave all your life and never have money. >> slave labor? without the maquilas imagine what would be going on in mexico right now.
without these jobs that are paying these people and providing them a safe haven and a career path and a goal and a dream, where would mexico be now? >> could a company be competitive in the us and pay a good living wage in mexico to have all their stuff assembled? >> no. they would get run over by the competition. >> beyond juarez's sprawling industrial parks, twenty five miles into the desert, lies a shelter. >> we're heading out to the desert, outside of juarez- going to a mental hospital of sorts, although it's not really a hospital. from what i understand it's really just a place in the desert where el pastor, pastor galvan, has taken people off of the streets, or the police have brought him people that have mental illness or fried from drugs or fried from all the
abuse that they've taken in jaurez and he takes them in and they just live out in the desert. matter of fact, this is it. fifteen years ago, pastor jose galvan began gathering people he found walking the streets of juarez and bringing them here. >> he gets to wear the us army uniform? >> well, he like to be, we call him commandant. >> now he looks after more than a hundred people. until now, he's received almost no funding from the mexican government, just barely scraping by each month on private donations to meet their needs. >> let me show you the clinic in here. twice a week the doctors come to check out the sick, tuesday and thursday.
this is the medication we have, so we need a lot of medication. we got medication only for 20 persons, the rest 80 persons, we can't afford it. >> twenty five years ago, galvan wasn't much different from many of the people he cares for now. a drug addict, he was arrested in the us, went to jail and got deported - and then was dumped in juarez. >> i was walking on the streets like one of them. naked, dirty, eating out of the trash cans but the lord changed my life. in 1987 i started a new life. i had it on my heart to be helping these people. >> the shelter is the final refuge for those whom mexico's public health care system has failed entirely, and left with nowhere else to go. do you think you'd have these people in any city or does jaurez have a lot of people who need help?
>> we got some 15000 persons who suffer from mental illness, plus the violence, the bloody city. juarez is the biggest mental institution in the world. it's the biggest. >> and as the drug war escalates, crime spirals and addictions take their toll, pastor galvan's shelter in the desert has grown to accommodate the city's living casualties. >> this is like a trash place, but this is a human place. all the trash people they came to here. because the lord is into recycling human beings. see all the people, i don't care what they did, it's not my concern. probably they got into drugs, killed people, i don't know what they did. but they lost their minds and they need help.
>> every sunday night al jazeera america presents gripping films, from the worlds top documentary directors >> this is just the beginning of somthing much bigger... >> tonight...the premier of "budrus" >> the primary concern of the fronts is security that trumps everything >> how could a wall designed to divide, unite israelis and palestinians al jazeera america presents... "budrus" premiers tonight 9 eastern. ç]
>> in juarez, a life in the factory is worth as little as $50 dollars a week. a life taken on the street is so cheap it almost never has to be accounted for. but the marijuana, cocaine, meth and heroin for which thousands are being killed are worth tens of billions on the us market - their prices inflated because they are illegal. >> if you want to know the biggest cause of death in mexico is the american drug prohibition. i don't know any other policy of any other nation on earth that says i'm going to go to mexico and give 30-40 billion dollars a year to absolute psychopathic murderers.
that's what us drug policy does. al qaeda couldn't do to juarez what the us government has done. >> the obama administration has repeatedly said that legalizing drugs, even some of them, is not an option up for consideration. over three months in 2011, the state department, the us embassy in mexico city, the us office of national drug control policy, the dea and the office of the united states trade representative all declined to be interviewed for this report. over those same three months, some 600 people were reported murdered in juarez. >> you're seeing is the drug violence, that's true, but underneath it you're seeing the disintegration of a nation, the economic disintegration, you're seeing people robbing each other, kidnapping each other, doing everything it takes to survive including killing each other.
but we can't face that, meaning the us government, we can't say there's an economic basis to this because that would mean our policies are a myth, our policy of free trade is a disaster. that would mean our refusal to recognize why people are coming north is a disaster. that would mean our war on drugs is a disaster. that would mean we would stop lying. this is like a machine now, of death. and i don't see anything that will stop it in the short run.
>> hello and welcome, i'm phil torres, talking about innovations that can save live. we'll do it in a unique way. this is a show about scientists. let's check out the team. kyle hill is an engineer. he's on the trail of something decimating bee population. >> crystal dilworth is a molecular neuroscientist. she shows us california's hi tech grapes - how science can achieve perfection in a glass. i'm phil torres. i'm an entermologist and i'll show you the spiders i found in peru. and how